The Grey Panel


Mothers superior

This column generally focuses on a stallion who has done well. In the week after Royal Ascot we would naturally be spoilt for choice, with several sires having posted commendable achievements. However, it is also a suitable time to remember that, with only a handful of exceptions, a stallion is only as good as the mares he is allowed to cover. This message was reinforced by the Ascot results, with a startlingly large proportion of the winners coming from mares who were either former high-class fillies or daughters of former high-class fillies (or, commonly, both). The Gold Cup has always been and always will be the feature race of the meeting, and it was only fitting this year that its winner should be a daughter of a truly special mare, writes John Berry.

A place-getter over a mile and a half in the Group Two Blandford Stakes at the Curragh in 1992, , a daughter of Darshaan, has now bred four individual Group One winners. To Sadler’s Wells she bred the 1997 Irish Oaks and Prix Royal-Oak victrix ; to Rainbow Quest she bred the 1998 Moyglare Stud Stakes winner ; to Kahyasi she bred the 1999 Ascot Gold Cup winner ; and now her four-year-old Monsun filly has echoed Enzeli’s finest hour by taking this year’s Gold Cup. Four Group One winners sired by four different stallions from three different sire-lines – and the only connection is their dam, herself formerly a high-class middle-distance galloper.

Most impressive weight-for-age victor at Royal Ascot was , who continued his seemingly relentless progress towards the summit by taking the Prince Of Wales’s Stakes. His dam (another daughter of ) was not a good racehorse (she only ran three times and was unplaced on every occasion) but Kazeem’s dam was very good: was trained for Sheikh Mohammed by the Guy Harwood to land an Oaks trial (the now-discontinued Princess Elizabeth Stakes at Epsom) in 1984 before finishing unplaced behind in the Oaks and second to the same filly in the Yorkshire Oaks.

When Al Kazeem notched his first Group One victory (in the Tattersalls Gold Cup at the Curragh in May) he became the eighth European Group One winner to descend from Kanz’s dam , the winner of stakes races in America at distances up to a mile and a full-sister to , champion two-year-old in America in 1959 and dam of . When sold to Sheikh Mohammed for $2,100,000 in 1982, Kanz became the most expensive yearling filly the world had ever seen. She duly became Treasure Chest’s best child. She was not the only good one, though: Treasure Chest’s previous foals had included the 9-furlong Grade Three winner (the dam of ) as well as the stakes winners Gold Treasure and . The latter bred the European Group One-winning Mill Reef full-brothers and , each raced (as was their sire) by their breeder Paul Mellon.

Another daughter of Crown Treasure to breed a European Group One winner was , a daughter of Caro who bred Sheikh Mohammed’s 1989 Irish 1,000 Guineas victrix , a daughter of Lyphard. Glint Of Gold’s and Diamond Shoal’s Kris half-sister visited the 1991 Derby winner Generous in 1995 to breed , a Group One winner over 2400m in Germany as a four-year-old in 2000.

From Gold Treasure descended the 2001 Italian Oaks winner , a daughter of In The Wings. And from Treasure Chest’s Buckpasser filly (dam of the John Dunlop-trained Group One-placed Group Two-winning stayer ) descended two European Group One two-year-old winners: and , sons of Rainbow Quest and Lawman respectively.

With Al Kazeem being a son of Dubawi, the conclusion has to be that the common link between the eight Group One-winning descendants of Treasure Chest is Treasure Chest herself, rather than any pattern shared by the various stallions who sired them.

The principal weight-for-age winner on the first day of Ascot was , one of two winners on the day for his hugely promising young sire . Both these horses (the other one being , who complemented Declaration Of War’s Queen Anne Stakes victory with an imperious triumph in the Coventry Stakes) are clearly great advertisements for War Front and his/their breeder Joe Allen, but they are also great advertisements for the families from which they hail.

War Command’s third dam was one of the best fillies in France of her generation, as she demonstrated in 1969 by taking the Prix Jacques le Marois (which, of course, was granted Group One shortly afterwards when the Pattern was brought into being) over 1600m at Deauville as a three-year-old. Her greatest achievement at stud was breeding the Roberto colt , who won the Craven Stakes over a mile at Newmarket in the spring of 1982 before being placed in both the Derby and Irish Derby. He subsequently became an even better stallion than he had been a racehorse.

Gris Vitesse’s other children included , a daughter of His Majesty who bred the Grade Two-winning Red Ransom filly – whose winning offspring now include (a son of Tale Of The Cat won the Group Three Prix de Conde in France as a two-year-old in 2008) and War Command.

Declaration Of War also descends from an top-class miler: his fourth dam , a daughter of the Hyperion stallion High Hat won the 1,000 Guineas in 1966. Glad Rags’ most talented child was undoubtedly the Nijinsky colt , a two-year-old for whom the sky appeared to be the limit until it came crashing down around him on Dewhurst Stakes Day in 1982: hot favourite, he performed as if he had been doped, finishing completed tailed off behind . He was never the same horse again.

In addition to Gorytus, Glad Rags also bred his full-sister Terpsichorist, a Grade Two winner over 10 furlongs in New York as a four-year-old in 1979. Terpsichorist’s best child was the Grade Two-placed Devil’s Bag filly , but she also bred , a daughter of Gone West who now ranks as the dam of the top-class (winner of the Champagne Stakes as a two-year-old in 2011 and of the following year’s Belmont Stakes) and of the winning Rahy filly Tempo West, dam of Declaration Of War.

Royal Ascot’s star three-year-old filly also descends from a filly who showed top-class form on Newmarket’s Rowley Mile: her grand-dam won the Rockfel Stakes in 1989 before finishing third to in the following year’s 1,000 Guineas. Negligent’s best foal proved to be the Singspiel colt , a Group Three-winning two-year-old over 1600m in France in 2002, but she also bred another very good two-year-old: the Shareef Dancer filly , a winner at York in 2005 before finishing fifth to in the Group One Fillies Mile at Ascot.

Shawanni has proved to be an excellent matron, having now bred 10 winners. These have included the Group winners and (a sprinter by Shamardal and a stayer by Hector Protector respectively) as well as the Listed-winning Spectrum colt – but the outstanding Sky Lantern, a daughter of Red Clubs, clearly ranks as the best of the lot. She will, in turn, surely follow her terrific racing career with a great second career at stud.

The lesson of Royal Ascot, then, is surely that we are right to take the selection of the stallions which we use carefully – but that we should be even more careful about chosing the mares from which we breed.

Archived General News Stories



ARGENTINA
Jump Start Garners 50th Stakes Winner Bloodhorse


AUSTRALIA
Street Cry Mare Tops Second Session of Inglis Sale Bloodhorse
Highland Reel to Swettenham for Southern Season Bloodhorse
Group 1-Placed Gypsy Diamond Tops Chairman's Sale Bloodhorse
Winx equals Black Caviar's record with 25th straight win Guardian
Strong Start to Inglis Easter Yearling Sale Bloodhorse
Happy Clapper Takes Doncaster Mile Bloodhorse all news
Winx's Connections Pass on Royal Ascot Bloodhorse all news
Royal Ascot raid yet to be confirmed for star mare Winx turftrax


BRAZIL
Emcee Sold, Heading to Brazil Bloodhorse


CHINA
China Moves Toward Allowing Racing in Hainan Bloodhorse all news


FRANCE
Olmedo Prevails at ParisLongchamp Bloodhorse
Final Scat Daddy tops 2018 Breeze Up Sale T'internet
Noble Mission Gets First Winner in France Bloodhorse all news
Cracksman lands Prix Ganay and looks to be on course for the Arc Guardian
Prix Ganay Returns to Rebranded ParisLongchamp Bloodhorse all news
Ryan Moore: The verdict on my big Sunday ride at Longchamp Betfair
Group Three delight for Chilean as ParisLongchamp opens its doors turftrax


HONG KONG
Pakistan Star stellar in Queen Elizabeth II Cup DRF
Ping Hai Star Rolls to Victory in Hong Kong Derby Bloodhorse
Hong Kong Locals Turn Out for Derby Bloodhorse
Premiere streaking into Bauhinia Sprint Trophy Press Release Feed


INTERNATIONAL
Experts at ARC: Illegal Betting Enormous Threat Bloodhorse all news
Gene Doping Threat Discussed at Asian Racing Conference Bloodhorse all news
Winx tops Longines Racehorse Rankings DRF
Arrogate Again Crowned Longines World's Best Racehorse Bloodhorse


IRELAND
O'Brien expects 'Saxon' to improve for Derby tilt Irish Independent
O'Brien Brings Three to Derby Trial Stakes Bloodhorse all news
Hazapour Comes Out On Top at Leopardstown Bloodhorse
Classy Kemboy rules at Punchestown to edge Willie Mullins towards another trainers' championship Irish Independent
O'Brien feels Moore is likely to chase Kentucky Derby dream on Mendelssohn turftrax
Order Of St George makes no mistake in Vintage Crop Stakes turftrax
Magician Relocated to Ireland Bloodhorse
Nelson sticks his neck out to land Ballysax turftrax
Gustav Klimt delights Aidan O'Brien with winning return at Leopardstown turftrax
Dual Classic hero Capri makes winning return at Naas turftrax
Happily heads Aidan O'Brien's team as 60 Oaks entries are revealed turftrax
Trailblazing Downforce powers to Listed success at Navan turftrax
Al Boum Photo denies Shattered Love in Fairyhouse thriller turftrax
Folsom Blue leads 13-strong team as Gordon Elliott seeks Irish National gol turftrax


JAPAN
Soul Stirring tops field of 18 in Japan's Victoria Mile DRF
Soul Stirring Looks to Rebound in Victoria Mile Bloodhorse
Rainbow Line vanned off after winning Tenno Sho DRF
Gold Dream Heads February Stakes Bloodhorse


KOREA
Illinois Derby winner Distilled dies in Korea DRF


NEW ZEALAND
Lazarus sold to North American syndicate New Zealand Herald
Almanzor Shuttling to Cambridge Stud in NZ Bloodhorse
Price is right for Prices at Premier Sale New Zealand Herald


SAUDI ARABIA
Proposed Saudi Arabian Race Could Rival Pegasus Purse Bloodhorse all news


SOUTH AFRICA
An Elusive Second Chance! Sporting Post
Graded Race Review 21st April RacingSA
Graded Race Review 7th April RacingSA
Graded Race Review 26th March RacingSA
Royal Mo to Stand at South Africa's Klawervlei Stud Bloodhorse


SOUTH KOREA
Breeders' Cup Marathon winner Afleet Again dies in Korea DRF


TURKEY
Papa Clem Relocated to Turkey for 2018 Bloodhorse


UAE
Benbatl far too good in Dubai Turf at Meydan turftrax
All-the-way Hawkbill shines in Sheema Classic turftrax
Jungle Cat shines in Al Quoz Sprint after Blue Point withdrawn turftrax
Vazirabad team set sights on Ascot after history-making third Dubai Gold Cu turftrax
Mendelssohn Provides All the Answers in UAE Derby Bloodhorse all news
Thunder Snow Upsets Dubai World Cup in Record Time Bloodhorse


UNITED KINGDOM
Rhododendron blooms for O'Brien in Lockinge Irish Independent
'Roaring' success points to 'Saxon' Derby claims Irish Independent
Harry Angel runs back into winning form at York and prepares for Royal Ascot Guardian
Derby favourite Saxon Warrior may have three stablemates at Epsom Guardian
Rostropovich stakes Derby claim with Dee Stakes victory at Chester Guardian
Billesdon Brook´s 1,000 Guineas win gives Sean Levey his biggest triumph Guardian
The Epsom Derby Antepost Betting: Saxon Warrior even money favourite Betfair
Saxon Warrior takes 2,000 Guineas for Aidan O´Brien Guardian
ustav Klimt can bag Guineas for master trainer O´Brien Guardian
Tamayuz Filly Tops Tattersalls Guineas Breeze Up And Horses In Training Sale T'internet
Katie Walsh retires from the saddle after thrilling Punchestown victory Guardian
Gosden's Lion to bypass Guineas Irish Independent
Slade Power's First Winner Arrives at Newmarket Bloodhorse
Masar impresses Appleby as he enters Guineas picture Irish Independent
Scat Daddy Colts Dominate Tattersalls Craven Breeze Up Sale T'internet
Soliloquy shines in Nell Gwyn at Newmarket turftrax
Forest Ranger foils Deauville in Earl Of Sefton turftrax
Star stallion Dansili retired from stud duties by Juddmonte turftrax
Scat Daddy Colt Tops Opening Day of Tattersalls Craven Breeze Up Sale T'internet
Canal Turn incident in Grand National to be studied by Aintree officials Guardian
National - What the jockeys said turftrax
Tiger Roll holds on to win dramatic Grand National in photo-finish Guardian
Kyllachy Colt Tops Goffs UK Breeze-Up Sale Bloodhorse
Cracksman and Enable headline superb Investec Coronation Cup entries racingfixtures.co.uk
Excelebration Colt Tops Tattersalls Ascot Sale Bloodhorse
Grand National hope A Genie In Abottle found dead with mystery illness Guardian
Altior on the heels of Sprinter Sacre with dashing Champion Chase success turftrax
Buveur D'Air digs deep to see off Melon in Champion Hurdle thriller turftrax


URUGUAY
Roman Rosso Scores in Latinoamericano Bloodhorse


USA
Justify Emerges From the Fog to Win Preakness Bloodhorse
Preakness win was imperfect, but Triple Crown in focus for Baffert, Justify ESPN
Red Ruby Gets the Trip, Takes Black-Eyed Susan in Slop Bloodhorse
Prado Eighth North American Rider to Reach 7,000 Wins Bloodhorse
Justify draws 7 post, is 1-2 Preakness favorite ESPN
Baffert: Justify still on track for Preakness ESPN
Digital Registration for Colt Born at WinStar Farm Bloodhorse all news
Kentucky Derby winner Justify a credible Triple Crown contender Guardian
Curlin's Honor Finds Redemption in Woodstock Stakes Bloodhorse
Justify wins Kentucky Derby in convincing fashion Los Angeles Times
Mud No Problem for American Gal in Humana Distaff Bloodhorse
Kentucky Oaks Day Handle Smashes Churchill Record Bloodhorse all news
Top International Owners Converge on Derby Bloodhorse all news
Monomoy Girl Digs Deep to Win Kentucky Oaks Bloodhorse
Kentucky odds against Mendelssohn Irish Independent
McCarron to Recruit New Owners Through Team Valor Bloodhorse all news
Starting Gate Suites Latest High-End Churchill Seating Bloodhorse all news
Justify Draws Post 7 as 3-1 Derby Choice Bloodhorse
Sunland Park Oaks Winner Blamed Out of Kentucky Oaks Bloodhorse
Tapit Leading Sire at OBS By Average Price Bloodhorse
OBS Sets Record as Lows Buy Session-Topper Bloodhorse
Awesome Again Moves up 2018 General Sire List Bloodhorse
China Horse Club Buys Into Oaks Contender Sassy Sienna Bloodhorse
OBS Spring Sale to Test Strength of Broad Market Bloodhorse
WinStar Holds Strong Hand in KY Derby as Breeder Bloodhorse
Timing strategy pays off for Nessy in San Juan Capistrano DRF
Giant's Causeway Dead at 21 Bloodhorse all news
Hustle Up First Black-Type Winner for Abstraction Bloodhorse
Magnum Moon Stays Perfect With Arkansas Derby Win Bloodhorse
Unbridled Mo Upsets Unique Bella in Apple Blossom Bloodhorse
Heart to Heart Dominates in Maker's 46 Mile Bloodhorse
Lemons Forever Named 2017 KY Broodmare of the Year Bloodhorse
Justify Favored in Final Derby Future Wager Pool Bloodhorse all news
Unique Bella strong favorite in Apple Blossom Handicap DRF
Midnight Bisou Blows by Rivals in Santa Anita Oaks Bloodhorse
Uncle Mo Colt Tops Barretts Spring 2-Year-Old Sale Bloodhorse
Midnight Bisou Clear Favorite in Santa Anita Oaks Bloodhorse
Hi Happy Notches First Stateside Win in Pan American Bloodhorse
hhh Bloodhorse


ZIMBABWE
Spies Rules In Zimbabwe Sporting Post